“The number of questions has been reduced from 31 to 27 in political science. Now there are five one-mark and five two-mark questions instead of 10 of each,” says Tania Joshi, principal, Indian School. “Children who are below average scored in these. Now there are more analytical questions. The marking will also be more subjective.” “We got to know about the changes when the sample papers came in and those came very late this year—in November or December,” says Joshi. The increased stress on long-answers will please college teachers—especially of the humanities and social sciences – but Joshi argues that bringing sudden changes also defeats the purpose of CCE (continuous comprehensive evaluation) which was to reduce stress.
The mathematics paper will carry 26 questions instead of 29; business studies, 25 questions instead of 30. More worryingly, there’s “no choice in the six-mark long question”. “There’d be a choice in every question before,” says Pooja Bahl, head of the commerce department, also at the Indian School, “We got to know when the sample papers were released in December. But the circular saying there won’t be a choice came in January,” says Bahl. There is also a clear shift in emphasis from short-answer objective-type questions to the long analytical kind. “About half the questions in the accountancy sample paper tests candidates on their higher order thinking skills (HOTS). They are application-based or interdisciplinary and don’t test the child on just understanding. In business studies, 60% to 70% of the paper is of this level,” says Bahl adding, “Some students—already performing well—are enjoying them. But we’re afraid they’ll impact performance of students who take time to assimilate.”
“We started uploading HOTS questions online every month after we got to know about the change,” says Usha Kaul, economics teacher at Delhi Public School, Mathura Road. The total number of questions has reduced from 32 to 29 in economics; there are eight six-markers now instead of six; and the number of one and three-markers has been reduced from 10 to eight in each case. They were able to incorporate the changes in their pre-board exams. “Only 20% of my students were able to score in the 90’s so there certainly will be an impact,” she says.
“Such changes are always based on the subject committee recommendations,” says a CBSE official. Though schools maintain that changes were announced late, CBSE claims this information was available as part of “curriculum documents” for a year. The idea, explains the official, “is to de-emphasize rote-learning and move towards more exploratory and evaluative lessons”.